Thoughts on Courteous Debating

Thoughts on Courteous Debating

The Critters newsgroup (sff.workshop.critters) has been deemed a No Flame Zone.

To encourage civil discourse on matters of importance, without invectives, a user posted these suggestions, herewith reproduced:

1) Exercise your writing skills by stating your point clearly in order to minimize alternative interpretations. Sarcasm, for example, might seem like an effective way of getting your message across. However, it is intellectually dishonest, and generally aims to score points rather than illustrate them. Be aware of the risk.

2) Check for understanding by asking if a poster really means what you think you are reading. For example: "Are you suggesting that coconuts migrate?"

3) Challange a postion, view point, thought process, mode of behavior, or method of expression. Never attack the person. For example: "That argument is based on the logical error of special pleading." Rather than: "I'm sorry you are too close-minded and defensive to agree with me."

4) If you are angry, walk away for a while. (Wait until tomorrow to write your reply, maybe even wait another day before you post it. If it's that relevant to life and the universe, time is NOT of the essence.)

6) Avoid the people you can't stand. (Use kill-files or just ignore them.)

5) Above all, think before you post.

DONATIONS

$
Critters is entirely funded by donations from users like you, so yours is most welcome. Click here to help keep Critters going. Thanks for your support!

WHERE TO?

Manuscripts
       (Forgot yer login/password?)
Submit
Woohoo!
Bios
Discussion Groups
Black Holes response times
Sitemap

Barnes & Noble

(Critters gets a pittance of support via advertising; Critters does not endorse any advertiser nor have control over ad content.)

SHARE THIS PAGE

Bookmark and Share

follow critters on twitterFollow critters on twitter

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING TO READ?

(Or want to collect money for other people reading your stories?) Check out Aburt's iFiction site.

CRITTERS DIPLOMACY

Fundamental to Critters' success is how people deliver criticisms. Start by reading Critiquing the Wild Writer: It's Not What You Say, But How You Say It. and The Diplomatic Critiquer.

NOVELS

Critters has a special program to get whole novels critiqued. Read about it here.

HOW TO SUBMIT

Please follow these guidelines for formatting and submitting manuscripts to Critters.

WHAT'S IN THE QUEUE

Critters keeps a queue of manuscripts out or to be sent. See the Queue.

WEEKLY MPC AWARD

Want to jump to the head of the Critters queue? The Most Productive Critter or MPC is Awarded weekly to encourage mo' better critting. How to win...

FAQ

Critters has an extensive FAQ to answer your every question.

CHECK OUT ABURT'S OTHER PROJECTS

Before you get or refinance a house or car loan check out Aburt's Ultimate Loan Scenario Comparison tool. (It's free, just a useful tool to save you money.)

[Guard your email -- get VirtID]
(Otherwise known as Aburt's spam-proof email.)

Andrew Burt

Create Your Badge